Here is a link to the article (which I heard about from David Hayward and his thought-provoking cartoons of awesomeness) should you be interested in having your brain leak out your ear… 8 Reasons to NOT Send Your Daughter to College.
It is full of gems like #1 She will attract the wrong types of men. or #3 She will not learn to be a wife and mother.
I. JUST. CANNOT. EVEN.
As you can imagine, my first instinct was to write a snark filled response going through each item one at a time.
example: #1 You mean like college educated men who value her for something more than her tuna casserole recipe or her child-bearing hips? See, not a good idea. Not loving.
I also thought about just reposting the list with the gender pronouns reversed.
example (emphasis added):
His: “So if it is unnecessary for one to be in a near occasion of sin, is it prudent to willingly put oneself there? This is no small matter we’re dealing with here. Is a degree worth the loss of your daughter’s purity, dignity, and soul? Catholic OB-GYN Dr. Kim Hardey [notice this is a FEMALE doctor who presumably went to a TON of college] notes that a woman is naturally very observant of a man’s faults as long as she is in a platonic relationship with him. Once she becomes sexually active with him, she releases hormones that mask his faults, and she remains in a dreamy state about him.”
Mine: So if it is unnecessary for one to be in a near occasion of sin, is it prudent to willingly put oneself there? This is no small matter we’re dealing with here. Is a degree worth the loss of your SON’S purity, dignity, and soul? Catholic OB-GYN Dr. Kim Hardey notes that a man is naturally very observant of a woman’s faults as long as he is in a platonic relationship with her. Once he becomes sexually active with her, he releases hormones that mask her faults, and he remains in a dreamy state about her.
Instead lovelies, I am simply going to give you
EIGHT 20 REASONS WHY YOU SHOULD ABSOLUTELY SEND YOUR DAUGHTER (and son for that matter) TO COLLEGE.
- A college education will provide her opportunities to learn and experience things she may not otherwise be exposed to. College provides not only classroom learning opportunities, but also opportunities to meet people from other cultures and faith backgrounds, which will make her world simultaneously bigger in her understanding and smaller in that she will make personal connections with people from around the country and the world. When she spends time with people different from herself it will make her richer and helps her realize that the image of God is present in all people.
- A college education will teach her to question things she has been taught are truth. This is always good because all truth is God‘s truth and truth has nothing to fear of questions.
- A college education will give her the confidence and security of knowing that come what may she can take care of herself. This will give her the power to leave an abusive relationship, survive the breakup of her marriage (God forbid), help to provide for her family, or provide completely if her husband dies.
- A college education means that she is more likely to marry, to stay married and to be happy in her marriage. She is also more likely not to say the #1 benefit of marriage is financial security.
- A college education will help her find her passion in life and help her to pursue her dreams even if that passion and dream is to be a stay at home mom.
- A college education will open doors to her that would otherwise be closed and she will be able to earn more money for any job she takes.
- Her children (your beautiful grandchildren) will be happier, healthier and more likely to get an education themselves. For example, obesity rates for children of college educated people are approximately 1/2 of that of the children of high school graduates.
- Education is its own reward. Your daughters as well as your sons will benefit far beyond their ability to get a job.
- The unemployment rate for people with a college degree is half of what it is for people with a high school diploma and one-third of what it is for people who didn’t graduate from high school.
- She will be less likely to smoke. “The percentage of four-year college graduates who smoked declined from 14% to 9%, while the rate for high school graduates declined from 29% to 27%.”
- She will be less likely to be obese and will be in generally better health. According to BMC Health and Carnegie Mellon, A high level of education has been linked to lower blood pressure and that college degree holders have lower levels of cortisol, a stress hormone, compared to people with less education. Also according to a 2008 study published in the Journal of the National Cancer Institute, men and women who earned a college degree are also at a lower risk of developing colorectal, prostate, lung and breast cancer.
- She will be more likely to have health insurance coverage. (According to a 2008 report by the College Board, nearly 70 percent of college graduates had employer-provided health insurance, while only 50 percent of high school graduates had benefits.)
- She is more likely to report high job satisfaction according to the Education Pays survey.
- If she is college educated she is more likely to marry someone who is college educated. When both parents are college graduates, their children (your grand babies, God bless them) will be more likely to go to college and reap all these benefits. It is a cycle of awesomeness.
- She is less likely to be incarcerated. Only .1% of all college graduates are incarcerated compared with 2% of the general population.
- She is more likely to volunteer and will spend more hours doing it. According to the Education Pays survey:
“Among college graduates, the volunteer rate is 46 percent, over twice the 22 percent rate for high school graduates.”and”Among those who volunteer, the median number of volunteer hours increases with educational attainment, with the 46 percent of college graduates who volunteer averaging 60 hours during the year, compared to 52 hours for those with some college, and 48 hours for high school graduates and for the adults with less than a high school diploma who volunteer their time.”
- She will be more likely to vote and have her voice and concerns represented. Again, according to Education Pays:
In the 2000 presidential election, 74 percent of U.S. citizens who were college graduates between the ages of 25 and 44 reported voting, compared to 45 percent of high school graduates. Among citizens between the ages of 65 and 74, 86 percent of college graduates and 72 percent of high school graduates reported voting.
- She will be almost 3 times as likely to donate blood to help others.
- According to the CDC she will live longer; almost 9 years longer than people without a high school diploma and about 7 years longer than those with only a high school diploma.
- And believe it or not, she is more likely to attend worship services regularly. A survey from the Association of Religious Data Archives shows that college graduates are the educational group that’s most likely to regularly attend weekly worship services.
11 thoughts on “So there is an article about the “8 Reasons to NOT send your daughter to College” on the interwebs and it makes my head want to explode.”
Great post! Fight the good fight! (nakedpastor)
Very well written post
Surely number 20 can’t be correct. I mean, we all know that universities are the bastions of anti-Christian Liberal indoctrination, hell bent on destroying God and kicking little puppies in the teeth.
Right? I am so glad neither you nor your wife work for one. 😉
Hi there I like your post
@Matt- #20 just may be correct. I am a college educated woman who is married and works full-time outside the home. I attend regular Catholic mass and send my children to Catholic school. Believe it or not, some Catholics do consider themselves liberal. My college ( a well-known Catholic university and no, not ND) was shockingly liberal when it comes to women, sexuality and homosexuality.
You might have missed some of the sarcasm in my post 🙂 My wife and I work at Universities, but we run into a lot of bad attitudes towards academia in some of our Church circles. Of course, those church circles would also stereo-type all Catholics as “liberal” (ie “not real”) Christians, so that would tell you a lot about their mindset. A friend of mine even once posted a rant on his FB wall about how colleges are destroying people’s faith with their “liberal anti-God agenda.” This guy was a youth pastor even.
Great response to a very distressing article! My personal response to the author’s first argument would be that his daughter would be less likely, not more likely, to end up with the wrong kind of man. Is this man that clouded to think that men pursuing an education are more lazy than men who are not? He seems to think about this issue only in terms of preserving his daughters’ “purity.” I doubt that would be the case with his sons. It saddens me that there are still some circles where an unmarried woman’s worth is tied up in their “purity”, while male “purity” is much less of a commodity. It only goes to show how women have more expectations set upon them than men.
I know this post is 3 years old but…
I came across this searching about my last Ob/GYN Dr. Kim Hardey. A very Catholic ob/gyn…(so there probably aren’t 2 strict Catholic Obgyn out there with the same name.
Dr. Kim Hardey is MALE. A MAN. He has a wife and two living children.
Just clarifying something you probably didn’t know….